I Sold Covered Calls for Income in Retirement — The Honest Results

A covered call looks like a paycheck, and for a while I believed it was one. I am 68, retired from operations management outside Columbus, and from January 2022 through June 2024 I sold calls on 2,000 shares of a broad-market ETF I already owned. I sold 10 to 20 at a time, strikes 5% to 10% above the price, one to two months out. $31,000 of premiums landed in my account.

For most of the first year I called that income I had generated. Then 1,000 of my shares were called away at a $195 strike while the ETF traded at $214. I kept a $4,100 premium and handed someone else $19,000 of gain.

That is the trade. The premium is not income, it is the price of a cap on the shares you still own, and the only scoreboard is total return on those same shares over the same 30 months. Net of everything, mine came to $2,920.

So before you sell a single contract, write down the price at which you would genuinely part with the shares. If it is not a number you would take with a clear head, the premium is renting out something you did not mean to sell. Then paper-trade one contract for 60 days and log the premium, the gain you missed, the fees and the tax you would owe.

The Covered Call Math at a Glance

💰
Gross premiums $31,000
📉
Upside given up $19,400
🧾
Taxes on premiums $7,900
⏱️
Time spent ~6 hrs/month
✅
Net advantage $2,920
📅
Duration 30 months

I sold calls on shares I already owned

I sold calls on shares I already owned

I sold covered calls on 2,000 shares of a broad-market ETF I already owned, plus the dividend stocks sitting beside them in the same account. That is the whole product: a contract giving someone else the right to buy my shares from me at a price I picked, and me collecting cash for that right up front. Nothing was borrowed, nothing was invented, nothing was sold that I did not already have in the account.

When I started in January 2022 the account held $420,000: those 2,000 ETF shares bought around $180, plus $60,000 in cash and short-term bonds. I was 68, retired out of operations management in Ohio, and the portfolio was what I had instead of a salary.

The mechanics were boring on purpose. Ten to twenty contracts at a time, each one covering 100 shares, one to two months until expiration, and strikes set 5% to 10% above wherever the ETF was trading that week. Do the arithmetic and somewhere between 1,000 and 2,000 of my 2,000 shares were under contract at any given moment. Half the position, at minimum, was always spoken for.

What that meant in plain terms is that every call had two sides from the first day. Premium came in. An obligation went out. The strike was not a wish or a target – it was a standing offer to sell shares I owned at that number if anyone chose to take it, and someone eventually did.

The worst case was never a margin call or a loss bigger than the account. It was delivering stock I already held, at a price I had written down myself. That felt safe to me when I started. It took a while to notice how much the safety depended on being happy with the sale price, which is a different question than feeling safe.

ItemCovered callsBuy-and-holdDifference
Premiums collected$31,000$0+$31,000
Foregone upside$19,400$0-$19,400
Fees$780$0-$780
Taxes$7,900$0-$7,900
Net advantage$2,920$0+$2,920
Covered calls vs. buy-and-hold over the same 30 months

The premiums added $31,000 over 30 months

The premiums added $31,000 over 30 months

The premiums themselves were real money: $31,000 landed in the account between January 2022 and June 2024. Averaged across those 30 months, that is $1,030 a month – and for a while that is exactly how I talked about it, as if the account had started paying me a pension.

It had not. The deposits were lumpy, and the lumpiness was the first honest clue. My best month brought $2,300. My worst month brought $310. That is a 7x swing between two months of the same strategy, driven by how jumpy the market was and by how far out of the money I set the strike. When I set strikes closer to the price, premiums rose; when I pushed them out, they fell. Volatility did the rest.

A real paycheck does not do that. It arrives on the same date for the same amount, twelve times a year, and you can build a budget on it. What I had was an irregular deposit that happened to average out over two and a half years, and I was treating the average as the plan.

Those numbers were also gross. They had not yet met $780 in fees and $7,900 in taxes, both of which came out of the same pile before anything reached my spending.

I logged every premium the day it settled, 10 to 20 lines a month, and added them up at each month end. That running total was the figure I quoted to friends at dinner. It was accurate and it was incomplete, because the second side of the trade did not appear in the same column.

📋 The covered call process I follow now

1

Pick the shares

Choose shares you would genuinely sell at the strike price, not shares you want to keep.

2

Check the calendar

Note the earnings date and ex-dividend date for the next two months before you look at any premium.

3

Set the strike

Choose a strike 5% to 10% above the current price that you would accept as a sale price.

4

Size the position

Write calls on no more than half your core holdings so one rally cannot cap the whole portfolio.

5

Log the trade

Record the premium, strike, expiry, fees and tax estimate the day the trade settles.

6

Decide before expiry

If the stock nears the strike, decide whether to roll, buy back or let the shares go before the last week.

7

Review quarterly

Add up premiums, foregone upside, fees and tax to see whether the strategy is still paying you.

Total return was the scoreboard, not premium income

Total return was the scoreboard, not premium income

That $31,000 deposit column only means something once it is netted against what the same 2,000 shares would have done with no calls written against them at all. So I built the other column: total return on the identical position over the identical 30 months, no premiums, no fees, no tax on premiums.

Premium of $31,000, minus $19,400 of upside that went to the buyers of my calls, minus $780 in fees. That leaves $10,820 before taxes. Then the $7,900 tax bill on the premiums comes out, and the advantage over simply holding the shares shrank to $2,920.

Over 30 months. On a $420,000 account.

Do the division and it is about $97 a month – roughly the cost of a modest dinner out, two and a half years of management, for which I also gave up the top of every rally I capped. The premium was never free money. The cost of it is the cap, and the cap gets paid on a date the market chooses, not one I choose.

Here is the part that took me longest to accept. The gross number and the net number were both correct; they just answered different questions. Gross tells you how much activity there was. Net answers whether the activity left you better off than doing nothing, and that is the only question worth asking before you decide to keep doing it.

⚠️ COMMON MISTAKE

The premium is not the profit

The premium is the gross revenue. The profit is the premium minus the upside you gave up, the fees, and the tax. On this account, $31,000 of premiums turned into $2,920 of actual advantage.

One assignment cost me $19,000 in missed upside

One assignment cost me $19,000 in missed upside

Of the $19,400 I gave up over 30 months, one call on October 17, 2023 did most of the damage. 1,000 of my ETF shares were written at a $195 strike, and the ETF ran to $214. Nineteen dollars a share – $19,000 – walked out the door and into the buyer's account.

I had collected $4,100 for that contract.

The remaining $400 or so came from a scatter of smaller calls that also finished over the strike, so the full price of the cap, all in, was $19,400. That figure is what my ledger calls the cap line, and it is the number that turned a $31,000 gross premium into a much thinner net.

The morning of October 18 I had two doors. Buy the calls back at a price well above what I sold them for, and eat the difference, or let the shares go and bank the strike. I picked the second door. For three weeks the cash from those shares sat earning next to nothing in my account while the ETF traded in the $205 to $210 range, a position I could no longer participate in.

That is the part a new covered-call seller is not told plainly enough: $4,100 was payment for a $19,000 promise. When I wrote that $195 strike I was not selecting a target to generate premium. I was setting a sale price and agreeing to hand over the shares at it, no matter how high the ETF climbed afterward.

The covered call terms that cost me money

📝 TERM Strike price The price at which you agree to sell your shares if the buyer exercises the call.
💰 TERM Premium The cash you receive for selling the call, yours to keep whatever happens.
📦 TERM Assignment When the buyer exercises the call and your shares are sold at the strike.
🔄 TERM Rolling Closing one call and opening another, usually at a higher strike or later date, often at a cost.
📅 TERM Ex-dividend date The date a call holder can exercise early to capture the dividend, sometimes taking your shares.
The ruleRead the strike as a sale price, the premium as payment, and the assignment as the bill.

Down markets got a cushion, not protection

Down markets got a cushion, not protection

Selling calls shaved a little off a decline; it never put a floor under the portfolio.

When the market fell, my portfolio dropped $38,000 on paper. Over that same stretch I collected $9,000 in premiums. The decline I actually lived through was $29,000. The premiums covered roughly a quarter of the drop, which sounds meaningful until you see the number underneath.

The reason is structural, and it is the part I had backwards going in. I still owned all 2,000 shares, so I carried every dollar of the downside of owning them. The call only paid me a fee for capping the upside. It is a one-way trade: the fee comes in, the obligation goes out, and nothing about a falling share price calls off the writing.

The worst part is when the money showed up. My worst month brought $310 of premium as the portfolio posted a five-figure decline. Volatility pushes premiums down just as it pushes prices down, so the cushion shrank exactly when my losses grew. That is the opposite of how I imagined it working.

So read this before your first sale: a covered call is not insurance. It is a small, lumpy payment for giving up the top of the return and keeping the whole bottom. If a decline would threaten your plan, the fix is the cash and bond allocation, not a line of calls on the shares.

Earnings and dividend dates caused the worst trades

Earnings and dividend dates caused the worst trades

The index could fall on me and I survived it; the two trades that actually cost me money came from dates printed on a calendar. One earnings report opened above my short call and my only move was to roll the contract out and up, closing the old position at a loss and writing a further-dated strike. That roll cost $2,600 in a single afternoon on February 1, 2023. It is the one trade in my whole log I would call a loss outright.

The second was quieter and worse. On an ex-dividend date a call sat just far enough in the money that the dividend was worth more to the holder than the premium I had collected. That holder exercised to capture it, 500 of my shares left ahead of schedule, and the early assignment was not on any plan I had written.

Now the calendar check comes before the order. On every position, before a single contract goes up, I look up the earnings date and the ex-dividend date and write both on the trade sheet next to the strike. No new call across an earnings report I have not planned for – either I close it before the bell or I cut the position small enough that a gap cannot hurt. For a new seller, this is the cheapest insurance there is: five minutes with a calendar.

Covered calls: when they helped, when they hurt

👍

When covered calls helped

  • Flat or mildly down markets, where the premium added income without capping much upside
  • Shares I was genuinely willing to sell at the strike
  • Positions without a large unrealized gain, so assignment did not trigger a big tax bill
  • Months when I had the time to monitor and log every trade
👎

When covered calls hurt

  • Sharp rallies, where the shares were called away below the market price
  • Earnings gaps that forced a costly roll
  • Ex-dividend dates that triggered early assignment
  • Low-volatility months, when premiums were too thin to justify the cap

It took about six hours a month to run

It took about six hours a month to run

The calendar work I described is the heaviest part of the month, and it never shows up on a statement. Add up all of it – scanning strike prices, typing orders, watching positions I already held, writing each fill into the log – and 30 months came to roughly 180 hours, or six a month on average.

Average hides it. Two months in the whole run needed nothing from me but a glance. Then an earnings month arrived, I rolled a short call out and up, and that single afternoon swallowed four hours by itself – the same $2,600 roll that stands as the one outright loss in my book.

So run the hourly rate on that. 180 hours against $2,920 of net advantage is a little over $16 an hour. My first real job in operations paid less, but I was 22 then.

the labor grows with every new position, and the money does not. Ten contracts on one ETF took nearly the same effort as one contract on ten different stocks would have, and the edge stayed flat. Twenty holdings would have meant twenty calendars to check every month for a return that barely moves. That is why I capped myself at a handful of names, and why I would tell anyone starting out to try one or two contracts before deciding they enjoy this enough to keep doing it.

Fees and taxes took a real bite

Fees and taxes took a real bite

The hours stung while I was doing them. The two charges that stung after the fact were the ones I had badly underestimated – the fee column and the tax column.

The fees were the smaller shock. Thirty months of option commissions came to $780, about $26 a month, and the broker took a bite on the way in and again on the way out. Every opening sale paid a commission; every roll paid one to close and another to reopen. The $2,600 roll from that earnings afternoon had fees stacked on it too, small ones on a big number, but they still went in the log.

Then the tax. The premiums were $7,900 of taxable income across the 30 months – nothing like income the IRS can't touch – and I sat down with my CPA to get it right rather than guess. How each contract is treated depends on whether it expired worthless, was bought back, or got assigned – and on whether the account was taxable or a retirement account – so I read the IRS guidance on options before filing anything.

Because here is what settled in for me: the gross premium was never mine to spend. What I could spend was the leftover. $31,000, less $19,400 of upside I never captured, less $780 in fees, less $7,900 to the government, left $2,920.

Are your shares right for covered calls?

✓
You would sell the shares at the strike price in a normal market
✓
You have at least half your core holdings uncalled
✓
You can spend about six hours a month monitoring and logging
✕
You would be selling shares with a large unrealized gain
✕
You need every dollar of upside to fund your withdrawal plan
✕
You cannot watch shares leave your account without regret
!
You have checked the earnings and ex-dividend dates for the next two months
ScoringOne bad is a warning. Two or more and covered calls are likely to cost you more than they pay.

I sell calls only at a real selling price

I sell calls only at a real selling price

With a bottom line that thin, the strike stopped being a number I picked for the premium and became the number I would actually take for the shares. That is the first filter now, ahead of everything else. If being called away at that price would leave me annoyed, the premium on offer is too small to cover the regret, and I pass.

The second rule is that no more than half of my core ETF position stays under contract at any time. I learned it the expensive way when 1,000 shares out of my 2,000 left at a $195 strike and the fund kept climbing to $214. Half the position was gone before I had a say. With half held back, a rally can only cap part of what I own.

Third, size each call so that a single assignment does not force me to rebuild anything. If losing those 100 shares at that strike would wreck my plan, I wrote too many contracts. And fourth, I leave alone any lot carrying an unrealized gain large enough that I do not want to realize it – assignment triggers the sale whether I like the calendar or not, and the tax comes with it.

The honest verdict: useful, but not a retirement plan

The honest verdict: useful, but not a retirement plan

Bounding the trade with rules makes it repeatable. It does not make it a living.

Thirty months of running this across a $420,000 account left me $2,920 ahead of where I would have been holding the same 2,000 ETF shares and doing nothing. That works out to $97 a month. It is not an income stream, it is not a withdrawal plan, and it does not fill the gap like dividends vs. selling shares could when I retired from operations in Ohio.

The stack of things that went right: 10 to 20 contracts out at a time, strikes 5 to 10% above the market, premiums that totaled $31,000, a scanner that screened a few names on Sunday. The stack of things that went wrong: a roll through an earnings gap that cost $2,600 in a single afternoon, 500 shares pulled out early on an ex-dividend date, 1,000 more called away at $195 while the ETF printed $214. Both stacks belong to the same 30 months. The verdict is that they cancel down to something modest.

It fits one kind of person: a retiree holding a slice of shares they would sell at a higher price anyway, with a few free weekday hours and the temperament to watch those shares leave without flinching.

It does not fit someone who needs every dollar of upside, someone who cannot stomach the assignment, or someone whose shares carry a large tax gain that a forced sale would trigger.

Start with one contract, not twenty. If the premium does not cover the cap and the work, skip it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a lot of money to start selling covered calls?

You need at least 100 shares of a stock or ETF you already own, because one contract covers 100 shares. On a $180 ETF, that is $18,000 for one contract. Some brokers allow smaller accounts to trade options, but the covered part still means owning the shares first. Start with one contract and see if the premium is worth the effort.

Can I sell covered calls in an IRA?

Many brokers allow covered calls in an IRA, but the rules and tax treatment differ from a taxable account. Check with your broker and a tax professional. In an IRA, assignment does not trigger a taxable event, but you also cannot use the premium to offset losses outside the account. The strategy still caps your upside, which is the main cost.

What happens if the stock price drops below my strike?

If the stock stays below your strike at expiration, the call expires worthless, you keep the premium, and you still own the shares. That is the good outcome, but remember you still carry the full downside of the shares. The premium is a small cushion, not protection. In my worst month, the portfolio fell five figures and I collected $310.

How much time does it take each month?

About six hours a month in my experience, including screening, order entry, monitoring and logging. Some months take less. Earnings months with a roll can take an afternoon. If you cannot commit that time, the premiums will not justify the cap and the mistakes will cost more than the income.

Should I buy back a call that is in the money?

Only if you would rather keep the shares than sell them at the strike. Buying back costs money, sometimes more than the premium you collected. In my case, I let the shares go and the proceeds sat in cash while the ETF kept rising. That decision cost me $19,000 in missed upside. Run the numbers on your own situation before you decide.

The $2,920 question: is the capped upside worth your time?

So here is the verdict by situation, not the sales pitch. If you would be genuinely content to sell a slice of shares at a higher price, and you can spare six hours a month, try one or two contracts and no more at first. If you need the full upside, cannot stand watching an assignment, or would be realizing a large tax gain on the shares, skip it entirely.

Either way, start on paper: sell one contract on paper for 60 days and write down the premium, the gain you missed, the fees and the tax you would owe. Do that before real shares go up as collateral.

I still check the same number first. The ETF at $214. My $195 strike. $4,100 collected, $19,000 gone.

The premium was real, and so was the cap. I believed the first and ignored the second, and over 30 months the distance between them was $2,920. Write both numbers down, and the paycheck will tell you the truth. That is what I would do again with mine – log it anyway, and at a price I would actually take.